Freelancing, fractional work, and consulting are three ways to work independently with nonprofits. The biggest difference is your role. Freelancers complete specific tasks the client defines, like writing a grant or updating a website. Fractional leaders fill a part-time leadership role, like development director, and work as part of the team month after month. Consultants bring expertise to solve a problem, like building a fundraising plan, and usually guide the work instead of doing all of it. Here's how each one works, where they overlap, and how to choose.
Freelancing: You do the work the client defines
Freelancers are hired to complete specific tasks. The nonprofit decides what it needs, and you deliver it. Common examples include grant writing, social media, graphic design, website updates, and event support.
Freelancers are usually paid by the hour or by the project. Freelancing can be a good fit if you like hands-on work and want flexible hours. Some people freelance alongside a job or between jobs, and others build full-time freelance businesses. The tradeoff is that the client usually decides what the work is, and when you're paid by the hour, earning more means working more hours or raising your rate.
Fractional work: You fill a part-time leadership role
A fractional leader does a leadership job for a nonprofit part-time, usually for a set monthly fee. You might attend staff meetings, manage part of the team, and be responsible for results in one area over time. Common roles include fractional development director, chief financial officer, chief marketing officer, chief operating officer, and executive director. Like consultants, fractional leaders usually work as independent contractors running their own business, not as employees.
Nonprofits often hire fractional leaders when they need senior experience but can't afford, or don't need, a full-time executive. Fractional work can be a good fit if you've led a department, want to go deep in one area, and like being part of a team. The tradeoff is that each client takes a big share of your week, so you can only take on a few at a time, and losing one makes a big dent in your income.
Consulting: You bring expertise to solve a problem
Consultants are hired for their expertise and an outside view. They figure out what's getting in the way and design a plan to fix it. Examples include fundraising plans, strategic plans, board training, and program evaluation. The work is often a project with a clear end. Consultants usually charge by the project or on a monthly retainer, and some charge by the hour.
Consulting can be a good fit if you like solving problems and want variety. Many consultants mix a steady retainer or two with projects. The tradeoff is that projects end, so you'll need new work lined up as they wrap up. For more on what the work involves, read what is nonprofit consulting and is it for you?
Is fractional work the same as consulting?
They're close, and many people use the words interchangeably. Some even call it fractional consulting. Both bring senior experience from outside the organization. The difference is your role. A fractional leader fills a position on the team for as long as the organization needs one. A consultant usually solves a specific problem or builds something the team can run without them.
I've done both. One client hired me as a fractional planned giving manager. I was part of their team and responsible for that program every month. Another hired me as a consultant to set up their individual giving program. I put the foundation in place, helped them hire a development director to run it, and stepped away. The goal from the start was to make myself unnecessary.
Where they overlap
In practice, the lines blur. Many consultants work on monthly retainers that look a lot like a fractional role. Fractional leaders give strategic advice. Some freelancers move into strategy work as they gain experience and trust. Plenty of people mix all three.
Either model can drift. A fractional leader can start to feel like part-time staff, answering messages at all hours and picking up work outside the role. A consultant on a monthly retainer can end up in the same place. The fix is the same for both: be clear with each client about your role, what's included, how you'll communicate, and how you'll be paid. For more, read how to set boundaries with nonprofit clients.
How to choose
All three are businesses. Whichever you choose, you'll decide what you offer, set your prices, and find clients. Ask yourself:
Do I enjoy doing the hands-on work, leading a team, or designing the plan?
Do I want to be part of one organization's team for months or years?
Do I want to go deep in one area with a few organizations, or mix different kinds of work?
How do I want to be paid: by the hour, by the project, or by the month?
How many hours a week can I give clients right now?
If you're starting alongside a job, freelancing or small consulting projects are usually easier to fit around your schedule than a fractional role. For more, read nonprofit consulting as a side gig.
If you're leaning toward consulting, the free consulting path quiz can help you see which services fit your experience.
About the author
Catalina "Cat" Parker is the founder of Relatable Nonprofit. She has a master's in nonprofit management from Columbia, her business has generated nearly $1 million in revenue, and 100+ nonprofit professionals have joined her Mentorship program. Read her story.
Want help building your business?
Whether you freelance, work fractionally, or consult, the Mentorship gives you six months of support to build your offers, marketing, sales, client delivery, and operations.